Learning Representations by Humans, for Humans

05/29/2019
by   Sophie Hilgard, et al.
0

We propose a new, complementary approach to interpretability, in which machines are not considered as experts whose role it is to suggest what should be done and why, but rather as advisers. The objective of these models is to communicate to a human decision-maker not what to decide but how to decide. In this way, we propose that machine learning pipelines will be more readily adopted, since they allow a decision-maker to retain agency. Specifically, we develop a framework for learning representations by humans, for humans, in which we learn representations of inputs ("advice") that are effective for human decision-making. Representation-generating models are trained with humans-in-the-loop, implicitly incorporating the human decision-making model. We show that optimizing for human decision-making rather than accuracy is effective in promoting good decisions in various classification tasks while inherently maintaining a sense of interpretability.

READ FULL TEXT
research
12/15/2015

Conditions for Normative Decision Making at the Fire Ground

We discuss the changes in an attitude to decision making at the fire gro...
research
07/02/2019

A Theoretical Model For Artificial Learning, Memory Management And Decision Making System

Human beings are considered as the most intelligent species on Earth. Th...
research
05/12/2022

Representation Learning for Context-Dependent Decision-Making

Humans are capable of adjusting to changing environments flexibly and qu...
research
06/14/2019

Personalized Apprenticeship Learning from Heterogeneous Decision-Makers

Human domain experts solve difficult planning problems by drawing on yea...
research
01/29/2018

Human-Machine Inference Networks For Smart Decision Making: Opportunities and Challenges

The emerging paradigm of Human-Machine Inference Networks (HuMaINs) comb...
research
05/15/2022

Trucks Don't Mean Trump: Diagnosing Human Error in Image Analysis

Algorithms provide powerful tools for detecting and dissecting human bia...
research
07/09/2020

When Humans and Machines Make Joint Decisions: A Non-Symmetric Bandit Model

How can humans and machines learn to make joint decisions? This has beco...

Please sign up or login with your details

Forgot password? Click here to reset