Privacy Preference Signals: Past, Present and Future

by   Maximilian Hils, et al.

Privacy preference signals are digital representations of how users want their personal data to be processed. Such signals must be adopted by both the sender (users) and intended recipients (data processors). Adoption represents a coordination problem that remains unsolved despite efforts dating back to the 1990s. Browsers implemented standards like the Platform for Privacy Preferences (P3P) and Do Not Track (DNT), but vendors profiting from personal data faced few incentives to receive and respect the expressed wishes of data subjects. In the wake of recent privacy laws, a coalition of AdTech firms published the Transparency and Consent Framework (TCF), which defines an opt-in consent signal. This paper integrates post-GDPR developments into the wider history of privacy preference signals. Our main contribution is a high-frequency longitudinal study describing how TCF signal gained dominance as of February 2021. We explore which factors correlate with adoption at the website level. Both the number of third parties on a website and the presence of Google Ads are associated with higher adoption of TCF. Further, we show that vendors acted as early adopters of TCF 2.0 and provide two case-studies describing how Consent Management Providers shifted existing customers to TCF 2.0. We sketch ways forward for a pro-privacy signal.


page 11

page 12


Conflicting Privacy Preference Signals in the Wild

Privacy preference signals allow users to express preferences over how t...

Beware of the Ostrich Policy: End-Users' Perceptions Towards Data Transparency and Control

End users' awareness about the data they share, the purpose of sharing t...

Ghanaian Consumers Online Privacy Concerns: Causes and its Effects on E-Commerce Adoption

Online privacy has gradually become a concern for internet users over th...

A Survey on Privacy of Personal and Non-Personal Data in B5G/6G Networks

The upcoming Beyond 5G (B5G) and 6G networks are expected to provide enh...

Consumer Centric Data Control, Tracking and Transparency -- A Position Paper

Personal data related to a user's activities, preferences and services, ...

"I have no idea what they're trying to accomplish:" Enthusiastic and Casual Signal Users' Understanding of Signal PINs

We conducted an online study with n = 235 Signal users on their understa...

Privacy Labelling and the Story of Princess Privacy and the Seven Helpers

Privacy is currently in 'distress' and in need of 'rescue', much like pr...

Please sign up or login with your details

Forgot password? Click here to reset