Effects of empathy on the evolution of fairness in group-structured populations

by   Yanling Zhang, et al.

The ultimatum game has been a prominent paradigm in studying the evolution of fairness. It predicts that responders should accept any nonzero offer and proposers should offer the smallest possible amount according to orthodox game theory. However, the prediction strongly contradicts with experimental findings where responders usually reject low offers below 20% and proposers usually make higher offers than expected. To explain the evolution of such fair behaviors, we here introduce empathy in group-structured populations by allowing a proportion α of the population to play empathetic strategies. Interestingly, we find that for high mutation probabilities, the mean offer decreases with α and the mean demand increases, implying empathy inhibits the evolution of fairness. For low mutation probabilities, the mean offer and demand approach to the fair ones with increasing α, implying empathy promotes the evolution of fairness. Furthermore, under both weak and strong intensities of natural selection, we analytically calculate the mean offer and demand for different levels of α. Counterintuitively, we demonstrate that although a higher mutation probability leads to a higher level of fairness under weak selection, an intermediate mutation probability corresponds to the lowest level of fairness under strong selection. Our study provides systematic insights into the evolutionary origin of fairness in group-structured populations with empathetic strategies.


page 1

page 2

page 3

page 4


Emergence and Stability of Self-Evolved Cooperative Strategies using Stochastic Machines

To investigate the origin of cooperative behaviors, we developed an evol...

First Steps Towards a Runtime Comparison of Natural and Artificial Evolution

Evolutionary algorithms (EAs) form a popular optimisation paradigm inspi...

Implementing Fair Regression In The Real World

Most fair regression algorithms mitigate bias towards sensitive sub popu...

Fixation probability and fixation time in structured populations

The rate of biological evolution depends on the fixation probability and...

Evolution of collective fairness in complex networks through degree-based role assignment

From social contracts to climate agreements, individuals engage in group...

Promoting Fair Proposers, Fair Responders or Both? Cost-Efficient Interference in the Spatial Ultimatum Game

Institutions and investors face the constant challenge of making accurat...

Toward Fairness Through Fair Multi-Exit Framework for Dermatological Disease Diagnosis

Fairness has become increasingly pivotal in medical image recognition. H...

Please sign up or login with your details

Forgot password? Click here to reset