Generative Interpretation

by   Yonathan A. Arbel, et al.

We introduce generative interpretation, a new approach to estimating contractual meaning using large language models. As AI triumphalism is the order of the day, we proceed by way of grounded case studies, each illustrating the capabilities of these novel tools in distinct ways. Taking well-known contracts opinions, and sourcing the actual agreements that they adjudicated, we show that AI models can help factfinders ascertain ordinary meaning in context, quantify ambiguity, and fill gaps in parties' agreements. We also illustrate how models can calculate the probative value of individual pieces of extrinsic evidence. After offering best practices for the use of these models given their limitations, we consider their implications for judicial practice and contract theory. Using LLMs permits courts to estimate what the parties intended cheaply and accurately, and as such generative interpretation unsettles the current interpretative stalemate. Their use responds to efficiency-minded textualists and justice-oriented contextualists, who argue about whether parties will prefer cost and certainty or accuracy and fairness. Parties–and courts–would prefer a middle path, in which adjudicators strive to predict what the contract really meant, admitting just enough context to approximate reality while avoiding unguided and biased assimilation of evidence. As generative interpretation offers this possibility, we argue it can become the new workhorse of contractual interpretation.


Digital Social Contracts: A Foundation for an Egalitarian and Just Digital Society

Almost two centuries ago Pierre-Joseph Proudhon proposed social contract...

LMs stand their Ground: Investigating the Effect of Embodiment in Figurative Language Interpretation by Language Models

Figurative language is a challenge for language models since its interpr...

CLAUSEREC: A Clause Recommendation Framework for AI-aided Contract Authoring

Contracts are a common type of legal document that frequent in several d...

ContractNLI: A Dataset for Document-level Natural Language Inference for Contracts

Reviewing contracts is a time-consuming procedure that incurs large expe...

Signature in Counterparts, a Formal Treatment

"Signature in counterparts" is a legal process that permits a contract b...

Between Subjectivity and Imposition: Power Dynamics in Data Annotation for Computer Vision

The interpretation of data is fundamental to machine learning. This pape...

Please sign up or login with your details

Forgot password? Click here to reset