Justice blocks and predictability of US Supreme Court votes

by   Roger Guimerà, et al.

Successful attempts to predict judges' votes shed light into how legal decisions are made and, ultimately, into the behavior and evolution of the judiciary. Here, we investigate to what extent it is possible to make predictions of a justice's vote based on the other justices' votes in the same case. For our predictions, we use models and methods that have been developed to uncover hidden associations between actors in complex social networks. We show that these methods are more accurate at predicting justice's votes than forecasts made by legal experts and by algorithms that take into consideration the content of the cases. We argue that, within our framework, high predictability is a quantitative proxy for stable justice (and case) blocks, which probably reflect stable a priori attitudes toward the law. We find that U. S. Supreme Court justice votes are more predictable than one would expect from an ideal court composed of perfectly independent justices. Deviations from ideal behavior are most apparent in divided 5-4 decisions, where justice blocks seem to be most stable. Moreover, we find evidence that justice predictability decreased during the 50-year period spanning from the Warren Court to the Rehnquist Court, and that aggregate court predictability has been significantly lower during Democratic presidencies. More broadly, our results show that it is possible to use methods developed for the analysis of complex social networks to quantitatively investigate historical questions related to political decision-making.


page 1

page 2

page 3

page 4

page 5

page 6

page 7


Predicting Indian Supreme Court Judgments, Decisions, Or Appeals

Legal predictive models are of enormous interest and value to legal comm...

Visualisation of Law and Legal Process: An Opportunity Missed

Visual representation of the law and legal process can aid in recall and...

Exploring the Use of Text Classification in the Legal Domain

In this paper, we investigate the application of text classification met...

Legal and Political Stance Detection of SCOTUS Language

We analyze publicly available US Supreme Court documents using automated...

Content-Based Spam Filtering on Video Sharing Social Networks

In this work we are concerned with the detection of spam in video sharin...

Algorithmic Fairness from a Non-ideal Perspective

Inspired by recent breakthroughs in predictive modeling, practitioners i...

Predicting the Law Area and Decisions of French Supreme Court Cases

In this paper, we investigate the application of text classification met...

Please sign up or login with your details

Forgot password? Click here to reset