Meta-analysis of few studies involving rare events

09/12/2018
by   Burak Kürsad Günhan, et al.
0

Meta-analyses of clinical trials targeting rare events face particular challenges when the data lack adequate numbers of events for all treatment arms. Especially when the number of studies is low, standard meta-analysis methods can lead to serious distortions because of such data sparsity. To overcome this, we suggest the use of weakly informative priors (WIP) for the treatment effect parameter of a Bayesian meta-analysis model, which may also be seen as a form of penalization. As a data model, we use a binomial-normal hierarchical model (BNHM) which does not require continuity corrections in case of zero counts in one or both arms. We suggest a normal prior for the log odds ratio with mean 0 and standard deviation 2.82, which is motivated (1) as a symmetric prior centred around unity and constraining the odds ratio to within a range from 1/250 to 250 with 95 empirically observed effect estimates from a set of 37 773 meta-analyses from the Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews. In a simulation study with rare events and few studies, our BNHM with a WIP outperformed a Bayesian method without a WIP and a maximum likelihood estimator in terms of smaller bias and shorter interval estimates with similar coverage. Furthermore, the methods are illustrated by a systematic review in immunosuppression of rare safety events following paediatric transplantation. A publicly available R package, MetaStan, is developed to automate the Stan implementation of meta-analysis models using WIPs.

READ FULL TEXT

page 14

page 15

research
09/21/2021

Network meta-analysis of rare events using penalized likelihood regression

Network meta-analysis (NMA) of rare events has attracted little attentio...
research
01/20/2021

Bayesian Meta-analysis of Rare Events with Non-ignorable Missing Data

Meta-analysis is a powerful tool for drug safety assessment by synthesiz...
research
06/20/2023

XRRmeta: Exact Inference for Random-Effects Meta-Analyses with Rare Events

Meta-analysis aggregates information across related studies to provide m...
research
06/29/2023

How trace plots help interpret meta-analysis results

The trace plot is seldom used in meta-analysis, yet it is a very informa...
research
06/09/2021

Verification and Validation of Log-Periodic Power Law Models

We propose and implement a nonlinear Verification and Validation (V V)...
research
10/29/2022

A comparison of priors for variance parameters in Bayesian basket trials

Phase II basket trials are popular tools to evaluate efficacy of a new t...

Please sign up or login with your details

Forgot password? Click here to reset